Too Bizarre To Be Bizarre

I had to read this one twice.

So a woman who lives in Utah was driving through the Nevada desert on December 27, 2011 when she hit a sagebrush, causing the vehicle to flip upside down. Unfortunately, the accident sent her husband, who was a passenger in the car she was driving, to the hospital, where he passed away on January 6, 2012. I’m sorry for the loss she and her family must have felt and still feel.

Now for the bizarre part of the story.

It seems Barbara Bagley, who was the driver of the vehicle, has filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against herself for alleged negligence in the accident that killed her spouse. You can take your time and read that line again if you’d like. Just in case you think you read it incorrectly.
Apparently, Bagley is the personal representative  of the estate of her late husband and is suing the driver, (herself), whose interests in the case are being represented by her insurance carrier. She is seeking an unspecified amount of money for damages that include medical and funeral expenses, loss of past and future financial support, the physical pain her husband suffered before he died from his injuries and the loss of love and companionship.
In her lawsuit, she claims she was negligent for failing to maintain a proper lookout and keep her vehicle under proper control.

A district judge dismissed the case in January, 2014 but last week, the appeals court reinstated the suit in a 3-0 ruling, stating that Utah statutes don’t prevent Barbara Bagley from seeking damages against herself. HUH????

The attorney’s representing Bagley against herself claim she is suing to meet her legal responsibilities on behalf of the estate, not herself. Right, she’s not looking to gain anything in this. 

So if I’m following this correctly and the lawsuit is allowed to continue, a jury would be asked to determine whether Barbara Bagley’s fault caused Barbara Bagley’s own harm. Then the jury would be asked to determine how much money would fairly compensate Barbara Bagley for the harm and loss she caused herself. If you’re confused, imagine what a jury would be going through, effectively asking a person to compensate herself.

As of now, the attorney representing one of the two Barbara Bagley’s is deciding whether to appeal to the Utah Supreme Court.

And the clock just keeps on ticking. And the hourly rates just keeps on adding up. And somewhere in Utah, there is a woman who thinks this is an appropriate path to take. But you know she didn’t come up with this on her own, right?

For so many obvious reasons, one can only hope that an appeals court feels differently and a financial settlement is not part of the end result.


4 thoughts on “Too Bizarre To Be Bizarre

  1. uju

    Where do you get these news from? I read it twice too!
    Anyway I think guilt is a great motivating factor. Maybe getting justice for her dead husband (weird as it is) will give her some respite.
    I wonder if a therapist suggested this…


  2. George Post author

    LOL…..sadly, I find these as I read the news. I would like to think she did this to find some sort of closure. Unfortunately, she probably had more than one attorney approach her and tell her she can sue the insurance company and hope for an out of court settlement. We are a litigious society in this country and this type of thing has become part of the landscape. Logic does not apply here.


  3. Mindy

    This whole case is a mess! I certainly hope it wasn’t her idea. I was rear-ended once by a girl who was speeding and cut across two lanes before she rear-ended me. Then she tried to get me to pay for her medical damages even though the police said she was the one who failed to maintain control of her MOM’s car and was in the wrong. Her lawyer obviously just wanted some money, but I was so mad!



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s